All the classic flavors you just can't live without are combined into one delicious package with this classic assortment featuring two (2) each of Nye’s bestselling sandwiches: Vanilla Chocolate, Strawberry Shortcake, Peanut Butter Chocolate, and Peppermint Chocolate.
Every cookie is hand scooped and every 3.5 ounce sandwich is assembled, wrapped, and packaged by hand at Nye’s.
Nye's Cream Sandwiches are small-batch handmade ice cream sandwiches. Just like the treat you remember growing up, only better! We updated the all-American favorite by pairing chewy house-made cookies with each ice cream flavor we make. What's more, every Nye's Cream Sandwich is prepared, assembled, wrapped, and labeled by hand. Sure, we could turn out a lot more if our sandwiches were mass produced. But that’s not what we’re all about. Once you taste our sandwiches, we’re confident that you’ll ask for Nye’s Cream Sandwiches by name.
We ship all orders overnight shipping. We ship Monday - Wednesday. Orders placed after noon on Wednesday will ship the following Monday.
We ship Monday - Wednesday. Any orders received after 12:00 p.m. on Wednesday will be shipped the following Monday.
To ensure the quality of our sandwiches, we only ship next day air in the highest quality insulated coolers packed with dry ice. For this reason, packaging fees apply to every order. Our coolers can accommodate 1-2 boxes of Nye’s Cream Sandwiches. Any additional boxes will be shipped in a second cooler and regular shipping and packaging rates will apply.
The sandwiches will arrive on your doorstep ready to be unpacked and placed in the freezer. In the event that the recipient is not present, FedEx will leave the package—no signature is required. It is the responsibility of the purchaser to make sure the recipient shipping address is correct and available for delivery.
We recommend that you make every effort to retrieve your package as soon as possible. While the sandwiches should remain frozen into the evening hours, outside temperatures during the summer months may accelerate the evaporation of the dry ice. Please do not handle the dry ice, as it will burn you.
If your sandwiches are not frozen when they arrive, please contact us and we will be happy to send you replacement sandwiches. In the event that your package is delayed due to weather or other issues with FedEx, you will need to file a claim with FedEx and we will assist in any way we can.
Any special shipping instructions should be included in the gift message box or called in before the order is placed.
Due to the perishable nature of our products, we do not accept returns. If you are not satisfied with your order, please call 910-859-7059, or email us on our Shop page.